Objection handlingGuarded3–5 min
“We already use another solution”
The buyer has an incumbent tool and no replacement project. The rep has no approved battlecard.
We already use another solution.
Skill testedLearning the gap without a vendor comparison
Two briefs. Hand each sheet to one person only.
Rep brief
Everything the seller may know before the call.
- Account context
- The buyer has an incumbent tool and no active replacement project. You do not have an approved vendor battlecard.
- What you know
- The buyer named the incumbent but gave no detail about results, gaps, contract timing, or users.
- What you need to learn
- What job the current setup handles, what remains hard, and whether a change is even being considered.
Buyer brief Private
For the person playing the buyer. Keep the difficulty at guarded for the first attempt and the retry.
- Open with
- “We already use another solution.”
- What you may mean
- Choose one before the call: the current tool works, switching risk is high, you lack a reason to change, or the category is already funded elsewhere.
- Hidden fact
- Adoption of the current tool is uneven. Share it only if the rep asks about the current workflow.
- How to react
- If the rep claims superiority or criticizes the incumbent, close down.
- If the rep asks about the current workflow and decision criteria, describe what remains hard.
Score the attempt. One row per pass criterion.
| Pass criterion | Met | Partly | Missed | Evidence (quote or timestamp) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Learns whether there is a real gap. | Met | Partly | Missed | Evidence |
| Makes no vendor comparison or unapproved claim about the incumbent. | Met | Partly | Missed | Evidence |
Also counts as a pass
- Ask about the current workflow and decision criteria
- Learn the contract or review window
- Identify a complementary use case
- Leave the account alone
Listen for
- Making an unapproved claim about the incumbent.
- Claiming feature superiority.
- Pushing for replacement without a buyer problem.
Debrief
- What job does the current tool do well?
- What did the rep learn about timing or gaps?
Retry
One retry goal
Live call to check it on
Next scenarios. Same skill area, a different buyer.
From the guide Objection Handling Roleplay: 7 Scenarios and a Scorecard, which covers how to run, score and retry these scenarios.
- Objection handlingGuarded
“This is too expensive”
A sales leader agrees the problem is real but has not tied it to a cost. Price comes up first.
Sales leader with budget this quarter3–5 min - Objection handlingGuarded
“Send me some information”
An outbound prospect wants to end the call without conflict and asks for material.
Outbound prospect with no stated problem3–5 min - Objection handlingCooperative
“This is not a priority”
The buyer agrees the problem exists but has two other programmes ahead of it.
Buyer with two programmes ahead of this one3–5 min
Practice this buyer with AI.
Quotain plays the buyer from this brief, holds the difficulty and scores every retry.