What should a sales call scorecard include?

A sales call scorecard should include the call type, five to eight criteria a manager can hear, a weight for each one, and a definition of what good looks like.

  1. Call type. Discovery, a demo, a cold call, a negotiation, and a renewal each need criteria written for that conversation.
  2. Five to eight criteria. A manager should be able to point to each one in the recording. A criterion nobody can find in the call gets a different score from every listener.
  3. A weight. The behaviours that change the outcome of that call should account for more of the score.
  4. What good looks like. One sentence per criterion, so two managers who hear the same moment land on the same score.

Score each criterion from 1 to 5. Multiply the score by the weight. Divide the sum by 5 times the total weight, then multiply by 100. A call that scores 5 on every line is 100.

A negotiation scorecard should include an accusation audit, labeling, mirroring, and calibrated questions. Those four follow Chris Voss. The builder starts a negotiation there, then adds a summary the buyer can confirm and a written next step.

For a sales rep scorecard you can open in Sheets or Excel, and call templates in Word and Markdown, read the sales call scorecard guide.

Build a scorecard for this call.

The builder runs in your browser. Copy, download, and print stay on your device.

Call type

Choosing a call type loads its default criteria and clears edits.

Criteria

Included weight is 100, so each point is one percent.

  • 15%
  • 20%
  • 15%
  • 15%
  • 10%
  • 10%
  • 15%

Add a criterion

Sales call scorecard

Discovery

Score each criterion from 1 to 5. Multiply the score by the weight. Divide the sum by 5 times the total weight, then multiply by 100.

  1. Opened on the buyer's context15 points ยท 15%

    The rep named why this meeting exists and what the buyer hoped to leave with.

    Score (1 to 5)Evidence
  2. Found the problem and its cost20 points ยท 20%

    The buyer described the problem, who feels it, and what it costs if it stays.

    Score (1 to 5)Evidence
  3. Mapped the decision15 points ยท 15%

    The rep learned who decides, who can stall, and what the buying steps are.

    Score (1 to 5)Evidence
  4. Quantified impact in the buyer's words15 points ยท 15%

    The impact is a number or a concrete consequence the buyer stated.

    Score (1 to 5)Evidence
  5. Tested fit10 points ยท 10%

    The rep asked a question that could end the deal, and accepted the answer.

    Score (1 to 5)Evidence
  6. Handled pushback with a question first10 points ยท 10%

    The rep asked what the concern was, and where it came from, before defending.

    Score (1 to 5)Evidence
  7. Locked a next step15 points ยท 15%

    The call ended with an owner, a date, and the work that happens before then.

    Score (1 to 5)Evidence

Total weight: 100

Weighted total

Score out of 100

The builder runs in your browser. Copy, download, and print stay on your device.

Starting criteria for each call.

These are the lines the builder loads. Turn any of them off, edit the wording, or add your own. Each set sums to 100 points.

Discovery

  1. Opened on the buyer's context (15 points). The rep named why this meeting exists and what the buyer hoped to leave with.
  2. Found the problem and its cost (20 points). The buyer described the problem, who feels it, and what it costs if it stays.
  3. Mapped the decision (15 points). The rep learned who decides, who can stall, and what the buying steps are.
  4. Quantified impact in the buyer's words (15 points). The impact is a number or a concrete consequence the buyer stated.
  5. Tested fit (10 points). The rep asked a question that could end the deal, and accepted the answer.
  6. Handled pushback with a question first (10 points). The rep asked what the concern was, and where it came from, before defending.
  7. Locked a next step (15 points). The call ended with an owner, a date, and the work that happens before then.

Demo

  1. Agreed the outcome the demo must prove (15 points). Before the product opened, both sides named the decision this demo should inform.
  2. Tied each moment to a problem the buyer named (20 points). Every feature shown maps to a problem from discovery, and the rep says that link out loud.
  3. Let the buyer interrupt (15 points). The rep paused at least twice and answered the buyer's question before continuing.
  4. Showed the workflow the buyer will use (15 points). The demo follows the buyer's job and uses the buyer's terms.
  5. Used proof that matches this buyer (10 points). The example is a similar team, problem, or constraint, and the rep says why it is similar.
  6. Raised the hard part (10 points). Security, implementation, or a missing capability came up while there was still time to discuss it.
  7. Closed on a decision step (15 points). The next meeting has a purpose, the people who must be there, and a date.

Cold call

  1. Earned the next 20 seconds (15 points). The opening names a relevant reason to stay on the line, then stops.
  2. Named a problem this buyer might own (20 points). The problem is specific to the buyer's role or situation, and the rep asks if it is real.
  3. Asked one question before the pitch (15 points). The first pitch waits until the buyer has answered something.
  4. Kept the first turn short (10 points). The rep's opening is short enough that the buyer can respond inside a minute.
  5. Handled the brush-off (15 points). When the buyer tried to end the call, the rep acknowledged it and asked one more useful question.
  6. Offered a reason for a longer meeting (10 points). The ask says what the buyer will know afterward, and how long it takes.
  7. Left with a time or a clear no (15 points). The call ends with a booked time, or with a no the rep leaves alone.

Negotiation

Accusation audit, labeling, mirroring, and calibrated questions follow Chris Voss. The last three lines keep the sheet usable on a commercial negotiation.

  1. Accusation audit (15 points). Before the ask, the rep names the frustrations or suspicions the buyer may be carrying, then pauses.
  2. Labeling (20 points). The rep names the emotion ('it sounds like', 'it seems like') and then goes quiet.
  3. Mirroring (15 points). The rep repeats the last one to three words the buyer said, then waits.
  4. Calibrated questions (20 points). Questions start with how or what, and the buyer has to explain the path.
  5. Summary that can earn 'that's right' (10 points). The rep summarizes the buyer's view until the buyer confirms it in their own words.
  6. Value before a concession (10 points). Price moves only after the rep restates what the buyer keeps, and names what changes in return.
  7. Next commitment in writing (10 points). The call ends with who does what by when, and the rep says they will send it in writing.

Renewal

  1. Opened with value already delivered (15 points). The rep named outcomes from this term, using the customer's own usage or results.
  2. Asked what changed (15 points). The rep asked how goals, the team, or the budget changed before talking about the new term.
  3. Surfaced the cost of leaving (15 points). The customer described what would be lost or rebuilt if they switched.
  4. Mapped the signature path (15 points). The rep knows who signs, who can stall, and the date the current term ends.
  5. Expanded where usage supports it (10 points). Any expansion is tied to a team, a workflow, or a limit the customer already hit.
  6. Paired a lower price with a trade (15 points). A lower price comes with a change in term, scope, or timing.
  7. Confirmed the renewal path (15 points). Owner, date, and the document that has to be signed are named before the call ends.

Practice against these criteria.

Practice against these criteria with Quotain AI roleplay. Run the call with an AI buyer, then review the score. Thousands of hours of calls have been rehearsed on Quotain. Start a 7-day free trial.

Questions about sales call scorecards.